Miraculous Crème de Menthe and Oreo Ice Cream – using ready-made vanilla

“Health food may be good for the conscience but Oreos taste a hell of a lot better.”

-Robert Redford

Don’t panic. This recipe does not involve fiddling around with masses of egg yolks, or finding the ice cream machine in the back of the cupboard. The only thing you have to do is to buy a decent quality ice-cream. Talk about passing off – some on offer should be illegal in my book. Go here for a post on which to avoid, which to go for, and how to choose wisely.

This ice cream tastes wonderful and, because it forms itself miraculously into three layers, it also looks wonderful. You don’t really taste the crème de menthe (probably a good thing – I find it a bit sweet and sticky) but it makes all the difference – the ice cream has a zingy, fresh taste.

Recipe for layered crème de menthe ice cream with Oreo biscuits

Serves about 20 people


  • 1 litre (2 tubs)/1.8 pints good quality vanilla ice cream (see above, re choosing a good one)
  • 16 Oreo biscuits (154g/6 oz pack)
  • 50g/2 oz (half a 100g bar) 70% plus dark chocolate
  • 3 eggs, beaten
  • 280g/2 cups icing sugar
  • 50g/2 oz (a fifth to a quarter of a brick) of butter
  • 80 ml/⅓ cup crème de menthe
  • you could garnish if you like with buds of mint


  1. Take the ice cream out of the freezer.
  2. Crush the Oreos with a rolling pin in a freezer bag.
  3. Melt the butter and the chocolate in a bain marie (do not let the top saucepan or bowl touch the water in the pan beneath it).
  4. Take off the heat and add the eggs and sugar.
  5. Pour into a high sided baking tin and sprinkle over the biscuit crumbs.
  6. Freeze for half an hour.
  7. Meanwhile mix the by-now-softened ice cream with the crème de menthe.
  8. Pour it over the now-frozen biscuit mixture.
  9. Refreeze again and serve.

This post is dedicated to David Johansson and Elaine.

Below, listen to Let It Go, from the Disney film, Frozen.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Related Posts

Christmassy cranberry and mandarin pies encased in pecan and white chocolate pastry

The Saucy Dressings team loves mince pies, especially, though we say it ourselves, our own. These are based on Jocelyn Dimbleby’s version which incorporates orange…
Read More

Iris’ always-reliable rhubarb crumble

This recipe was given to me by a lady who worked with us many years ago and who sadly died of breast cancer. I have…
Read More

A very pretty lemon tart whipped up with a magic spoon aka Tarte au citron

“’You make a mistake if you don’t try to figure out love,’ he said now as he served the tarte au citron—boldly tangy with…
Read More

Sign up to our Saucy Newsletter

subscribe today for monthly highlights of foodie events, new restaurant at home menus, recipe ideas and our latest blog posts